Abstract

The Matrix subverts Platonic idealism, portraying mental constructs as deceptive and suggesting that true reality and freedom lie in the material world. Instead of extolling the Platonic valuation of a changeless, transcendent realm of mental essence, it proposes that deception resides within the mind while matter holds the ultimate truth. This inversion critiques idealism, asserting the primacy of a material ontology, and prioritizing freedom above all other values, contrasting starkly with the Platonic pursuit of knowledge or happiness. In this light, The Matrix exemplifies the Western ideals of the turn of the millennium: an individualistic, unyielding love of liberty, even at the expense of traditional Western values.

Introduction

Educators frequently compare The Matrix to a modern rendition of Plato's Allegory of the Cave, a perennial philosophical parable.1 In Plato's allegory, prisoners are shackled within a cave, able only to perceive shadows cast upon a wall by unseen figures.2 One prisoner manages to escape and, though initially blinded by the world outside the cave, gradually perceives the reality of truth beyond the cave. Upon returning to enlighten his fellow prisoners, he is met with derision and resistance, as they prefer the comfort of shadows to the harsh brightness of truth.

On a superficial level, The Matrix mimics this narrative structure, offering a revelation that appears Platonic. Yet, the substance and ramifications of this revelation diverge significantly from Platonic Idealism. Plato's philosophy anchors reality in a transcendent domain of ideal forms, accessible through mental recollection and intellectual insight, as elucidated by Socrates in the dialogues.

Conversely, Aristotle, Plato's pupil, grounded philosophical realism in the physical and material world, apprehensible through empirical observation and sensory experience. This philosophical divide is famously depicted in Raphael's painting, The School of Athens, where Plato points upward, indicating his belief in transcendent forms, while Aristotle gestures outward, signifying his commitment to empirical reality. This enduring dialectic between idealism and realism underpins much of Western philosophical discourse, reflecting a tension between the transcendent and the empirical.

The Matrix disrupts Platonic idealism's seamless contribution to Western thought by suggesting that mental constructs are deceptive, and genuine liberation lies within the material world. Neo's journey, from his initial encounters with agents to his final awakening, epitomizes the shift from idealistic delusions to material reality. The early scenes—the agents' interrogation of Neo and the implantation of the tracker—underscore the mind's deceit and Neo's eventual deliverance. These moments lay the groundwork for The Matrix to reexamine notions of reality and the virtue of freedom.

Idealism and Realism

Before continuing, it would behoove us to distinguish between the concepts of idealism and realism as they are understood in both philosophical and literary contexts. This distinction will provide a clearer lens through which to analyze the film’s narrative and thematic explorations.

In Philosophy

Philosophical idealism posits that reality is fundamentally mental, spiritual, or immaterial. Esteemed philosophers such as Plato and Berkeley argue that the material world is either an illusion or subordinate to the mental or spiritual realm. Plato’s theory of forms, for example, suggests that true reality exists in an abstract, unchanging realm of perfect forms, accessible through intellectual insight and contemplation.3 Berkeley extends this notion, asserting that material objects do not exist independently of our perceptions but are sustained by the mind or a divine spirit.4

In stark contrast, philosophical realism maintains that reality exists independently of our perceptions and can be comprehended through empirical observation and sensory experience. Aristotle, a student of Plato and prominent advocate of realism, contends that the physical world and natural phenomena constitute true reality.5 He emphasizes the importance of sensory experience and empirical evidence in understanding the world around us.6

In Literature

Literary idealism, on the other hand, involves the portrayal of characters, settings, and narratives in a manner that emphasizes ideals, aspirations, and the pursuit of higher virtues.7 Idealistic literature often features noble heroes, moral dilemmas, and themes of hope, justice, and the triumph of good over evil. It focuses on what could be rather than what is, presenting a romanticized or utopian vision of the world.8

Conversely, literary realism strives to depict life and society with accuracy and truthfulness, devoid of idealization or romanticization.9 Realistic literature may include detailed descriptions, complex characters with believable emotions and motivations, and plots that reflect real-life issues and scenarios. It focuses on the mundane and the factual, often highlighting social issues, personal struggles, and the human condition in a straightforward manner.

By understanding these distinctions, we can better appreciate how The Matrix navigates between these philosophical and literary traditions.

How Do You Define Real?

Before Neo’s actual awakening, his encounters with the agents serve as foreshadowing of the larger reality he is about to confront. For instance, during an 'interview' with the agents, they threaten him, suggesting he is entangled in something far more extensive than he has realized. This encounter marks the first sign that Neo is on the brink of entering a complex and perilous world beyond his mundane existence.

Matters escalate when the agents raid Neo’s workplace, turning his world upside down. Neo’s confusion and disbelief are captured in his protest, "I didn’t do anything," revealing his inability to grasp the unfolding events. This ignorance persists as he is taken into custody and interrogated by the agents. During the interrogation, Neo defies them, showing his resistance by giving them the middle finger when they offer him a chance to cooperate.

The agents further demonstrate their control over the environment by manipulating Neo’s body: they seal his mouth and implant a tracker inside him. These actions vividly illustrate the extent of their power and the malleability of reality within the Matrix. Moreover, the implantation of the tracker symbolizes their control over Neo and marks the beginning of his journey from deception to truth.

Techgnosis

Neo's journey mirrors the pattern of idealistic gnosis described by Plato in his Allegory of the Cave. In the Allegory, it is the escape of the prisoner that brings enlightenment and reveals a higher, perfect reality. In contrast, in The Matrix, Neo awakens to a vastly different truth.

The act of taking the red pill and the subsequent liquefaction of the mirror symbolize the passage from illusion to material reality. This awakening reveals a dystopian, harsh reality rather than a transcendent, perfect world. When Neo takes the red pill, the process is rigorous and disorienting. The mirror turns liquid and crawls up his body as digital sounds intensify, reflecting the urgency and discomfort of transitioning from illusion to reality, starkly contrasting with Plato’s serene enlightenment of the escaped prisoner.

Neo finally wakes up in a pod, a stark reversal of the conventional image of birth. He is bald, immobile, and nearly blind, encased in a fluid-filled, egg-like structure reminiscent of an embryo. However, this birth is devoid of innocence and promise. Neo, now an adult male, is weak and helpless, emphasizing the brutality of his new reality. The pod, a cold mechanical construct, resembles an insect’s cocoon more than a nurturing mother’s womb, highlighting the dehumanizing nature of this new world. Seeing thousands or millions of others in similar pods further strips Neo’s rebirth of any uniqueness, presenting a dystopian hive that underscores the material world’s harshness. Instead of a comforting presence at birth, Neo is examined by an insect-like machine that deems him unfit and disposes of him like waste. This mechanized rejection contrasts sharply with the ideal of a mother cradling her newborn. Neo’s first experience in the real world is one of rejection and disposability, further emphasizing the material reality’s harshness and brutality. After being discarded, Neo is lifted to the sky by a mechanical arm and bathed in light, evoking imagery of divine intervention or the harrowing of hell. This too is revealed to be a mechanical rather than divine process. Neo then boards a ship and meets those he encountered in the Matrix in their true forms.

These true forms are far less impressive than their virtual counterparts; they are shabby, less beautiful, less powerful, and less well-adorned. The world outside the Matrix is gray and dour, populated by vulnerable and ragtag human beings. While the ideal of Plato is not, in a technical sense, equated with the colloquial “ideal,” it may as well be. The ancient Hellenes had a great admiration for the stable and unchanging associated with the ideal. Thus, the colloquial use of the word is expressing the technical/historical sense well enough. Thus, when we encounter these shabby forms, they can be understood as “unidealized.”10

A series of hints and near misses builds up to Neo’s actual awakening, marking his transition from the mundane to the fantastic world of the Matrix. These moments are reminiscent of a portal story, where the protagonist moves from an ordinary, recognizable world to a strange and often threatening reality.11 Unlike most portal stories that lead to an idealized or magical realm,12 Neo’s passage leads to a rundown, dystopian reality that is highly realistic. The material world Neo enters is not beautiful or idealized—the typical setting for this type of narrative – but harsh, cold, and devoid of any idealist notions of a transcendental reality. This contrast highlights the film’s rejection of idealism and its emphasis on material ontology. The fact that people in this world value its reality despite its cruelty supports the view that authentic liberty lies in the material world, free from idealistic delusions.

Material Affirmations

In one pivotal moment, Neo, still grappling with his skepticism, exclaims during a training session within the construct, "This isn't real." His seasoned mentor, Morpheus, responds with a profound question that strikes at the core of the film's philosophical inquiry:

What is real? How do you define 'real'?" He continues, "If you're talking about what you can feel, what you can smell, what you can taste and see, then 'real' is just electrical signals interpreted by your brain.

This dialogue urges both Neo and the audience to reassess their understanding of reality.

Despite the ambiguity Morpheus introduces, the overarching narrative of The Matrix ultimately affirms the reality of the material world outside the Matrix.

This affirmation is rooted in Morpheus's recounting of a war between humans and machines. In detailing the collapse of human civilization, the rise of the machines, and the subsequent enslavement of humanity within the Matrix, he conveys a history that does not add another layer of illusion but rather presents essential truth that demands their struggle for freedom. By alienating the material world through this historical account, Morpheus underscores the innate and immediate nature of their fight: humans were once free but are now harvested and exploited by machines as an energy source. The stark, chilling details of this history stand in sharp contrast to the simulated comfort of the Matrix, emphasizing the harshness and urgency of the material world. Morpheus’s actions and convictions unequivocally reaffirm that the material world—where the battle against the machines occurs—is the true reality to which he invites Neo to join their cause and fight for human liberation.

This material emphasis is further highlighted through the training sessions within the construct. Morpheus uses the construct to equip Neo with skills necessary for survival and combat in the real world. It becomes abundantly clear that the training conducted within the construct has tangible effects on their actual fight against the machines, thus underscoring the mission's material orientation.

Morpheus frequently returns to the physical constraints and dangers of the natural world, pointing out that an injury sustained within the Matrix can be fatal because one's body cannot survive without one's mind. This connection to reality is thereby bound to the material world, where harm inflicted is real and irreversible.

A Prison That You Cannot Taste or See or Touch

The Matrix immerses viewers in the ongoing debate between idealism and realism, presenting a contemporary interpretation of these philosophical perspectives through its narrative. It portrays these mental constructs as deceptive illusions engineered by machines to subjugate humanity. The simulated reality within the Matrix is designed to provide humans with a false sense of comfort and normalcy, preventing them from recognizing the grim truth of their physical enslavement. This inversion of Platonic idealism13 suggests that the mind can be manipulated rather than serve as a gateway to higher truths.

It anchors its narrative in a physical world where bodily freedom and survival are paramount. The film suggests that true liberation and authenticity lie in confronting and embracing the material reality, no matter how dystopian it may be. The characters’ struggle to free themselves from the Matrix and reclaim their autonomy underscores the importance of engaging with the tangible world, rather than retreating into comforting illusions.

The Nebuchadnezzar

The crew of the Nebuchadnezzar embodies the film’s materialist message. These ordinary men and women are dedicated to the struggle for freedom, emphasizing the importance of physical action and resistance. Their united front against the machines represents a collective commitment to their cause. Their collective struggle underscores the film’s message that true liberation is rooted in a physical perspective. This section will introduce some of its key members.

Morpheus

Morpheus embodies the archetypal mentor, staunchly believing in the reality of the material world. His conviction propels the plot and drives Neo’s transformation. Morpheus perceives the Matrix as an illusion and is unwaveringly committed to the reality beyond it. His quest to find "The One" who can liberate humanity is firmly rooted in his belief in the material world. He recounts the history of human enslavement by machines as an undeniable fact, again reiterating the perspective they are in the real, physical world.

Morpheus’s realist perspective is underscored in his dialogues and actions. He stresses the significance of the material world and the necessity of fighting for freedom. His dedication to training Neo for physical combat reflects the practical focus of their mission. Morpheus frequently points out that injuries sustained in the Matrix can be fatal because the body cannot survive without the mind, reinforcing the importance of their physical existence.

Trinity

Trinity plays a vital role in Neo’s journey, reinforcing the film’s materialist message. Her belief in the reality of their mission complements Morpheus’s teachings. Trinity’s unwavering faith in Neo’s potential is crucial, helping him confront the harsh realities post-awakening. Their developing relationship illustrates the natural connections in a material world. Trinity’s love for Neo, transcending the illusions of the Matrix, affirms the reality and significance of their physical existence and emotions. Her combat skills and leadership underscore the importance of the material world in their fight against the machines.

Cypher

Cypher is a pivotal foil to Neo and Morpheus, embodying the allure of idealistic illusions and the inherent challenges of embracing harsh reality. His yearning to return to the comforts of the Matrix underscores the seductive nature of illusion, and serves as a sharp critique of idealism within the film’s narrative.

Unlike Neo, who seeks truth despite its discomfort, Cypher longs for the blissful ignorance provided by the Matrix. This is vividly illustrated in a scene where he dines with Agent Smith. As he enjoys a succulent steak, he acknowledges its artificial nature but savors it nonetheless, declaring, “Ignorance is bliss.”14 This moment epitomizes his preference for illusion over the stark reality of the world outside the Matrix.

This scene is laden with symbolism. The steak represents the comforts and pleasures of the illusory world, while Cypher’s deliberate choice to remain ignorant underscores the powerful pull of idealism. His longing for the Matrix mirrors a broader human tendency to favor comforting falsehoods over uncomfortable truths. Cypher’s actions reveal a desire for simplicity and ease, even at the cost of autonomy and freedom.

Furthermore, Cypher’s dissatisfaction with the real world and his decision to betray his comrades highlight the emotional toll of embracing reality. His disillusionment with the harsh conditions aboard the Nebuchadnezzar and the bleak prospects of their struggle against the machines propel him toward betrayal. This inner conflict underscores the resilience required to accept and live in the material world. Unlike Neo and Morpheus, who find meaning in their fight for freedom, Cypher views the struggle as futile and reality as unbearably grim.

Cypher’s actions also illuminate the philosophical tension between idealism and realism. His choice to return to the Matrix symbolizes a retreat into idealistic fantasies, where reality is constructed and controlled, providing comfort and certainty. This retreat contrasts sharply with Morpheus and Neo’s materialist worldview, which sees embracing the uncertainty and struggle of the real world as the path to true liberation.

In betraying his comrades, Cypher embodies the existential crisis that often accompanies the confrontation with reality. His character raises critical questions about happiness and the human capacity to endure suffering for the sake of truth. Cypher’s betrayal highlights the difficulty of maintaining a commitment to material reality when faced with the persistent allure of idealistic escape.

The philosophical implications of Cypher’s actions challenge the audience to reflect on their own inclinations toward idealism and realism. Cypher’s narrative arc serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of succumbing to the comfort of illusions and abandoning the quest for an authentic existence. His ultimate fate, being killed by Tank after attempting to murder his shipmates, serves as a stark reminder of the cost of betrayal and the peril of choosing illusion over reality.

Cypher enriches the film’s narrative by presenting a counterpoint to the hero’s journey, highlighting the resilience and courage required to confront and accept reality, by making their lack seem so villainous.

Non-Platonic Idealism

Neo’s journey in The Matrix introduces a philosophical twist. Initially, his quest for truth mirrors the philosopher's ascent from Plato’s cave. However, the film diverges from Platonic idealism, which posits that ultimate reality is found in an abstract, unchanging realm of forms. Instead, The Matrix situates reality firmly in the material world, starkly contrasting with Plato’s idealized vision of beauty and perfection. This shift reflects a broader cultural critique that questions the stability of traditional values and embraces a more material perspective on reality.15

Neo’s awakening reveals a reality that is dystopian, harsh, and unforgiving. This material world, stripped of idealistic beauty and transcendence, is where the film locates true liberation and authenticity. Despite its harshness, the inhabitants of this world value its reality, underscoring the film’s critique of idealism. It suggests that engaging with the tangible, empirical world is crucial, rather than retreating into abstract ideals.

Moreover, the film elevates liberty as a transcendent value. This emphasis on individual freedom above all else, even at the expense of other values, marks a radical departure from traditional Western ideals shaped by Platonic thought. Morpheus’s depiction of those trapped in the Matrix as “slaves” reinforces this message. He speaks of mental enslavement and the necessity of liberation through engagement with the material world. This philosophical shift challenges viewers to reconsider the nature of reality and the values that define human existence.

Conclusions

The Matrix reexamines Western thought, engaging critically with the longstanding debate between realism and idealism. The film aligns with the materialist viewpoint, yet it does so without discarding the valuable ethos embedded within Western values. By grounding reality in the material world and asserting liberty as the highest value, The Matrix calls for a nuanced reevaluation of our philosophical heritage.

This narrative captures the spirit of the turn of the millennium, a period marked by sociocultural critique and growing disillusionment with aspects of modernity.16 The technological advancements and cultural shifts of the era fostered a sense of fatigue with many traditional Western values. However, amid this backdrop, The Matrix champions the notion that, even in a universe devoid of transcendence, there remains a profound cause worth fighting for: freedom.

By endorsing a realist ontology while maintaining the significance of a literary idealism that aspires to higher virtues, The Matrix encapsulates the tension between disillusionment and hope characteristic of its time.

In the end, The Matrix prompts a recognition of the importance of material reality while simultaneously striving for the higher moral and ethical aspirations that can be considered, in a literary sense, idealistic. It, therefore, subverts one form of idealism while affirming another, and deals much the same with realism. In doing so, it offers a snapshot of a unique moment in cultural and philosophical history, reflecting both the anxieties and the aspirations of an era in flux.

Bibliography

Aristotle. Metaphysics. Translated by W.D. Ross. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1924.

Barros, Michael. “Spooky Spiritual Spaces Subverting Secularity.” The Classical Connection 1, no. 1 (2023). https://doi.org/10.21428/3c891a13.c1059033.

Bartleby. "A Comparison of The Matrix and Plato’s Allegory of the Cave." Accessed June 18, 2024. https://www.bartleby.com/essay/A-Comparison-of-The-Matrix-and-Platos-FKJWJ2RYVC.

Berkeley, George. A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge. Edited by Jonathan Dancy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998.

Daily Philosophy. "Plato's Theory of Forms." Accessed June 18, 2024. https://daily-philosophy.com/plato-theory-of-forms/.

Eagleton, Terry. The Ideology of the Aesthetic. Blackwell, 1990.

Einzelganger. "All I’m Offering Is the Truth | The Philosophy of The Matrix." May 19, 2022. https://einzelganger.co/all-im-offering-is-the-truth-the-philosophy-of-the-matrix/.

Epstein, Adam. "At 20, The Matrix and Its Cyberpunk Philosophy Still Resonate." Quartz. March 29, 2019. https://qz.com/quartzy/1583555/at-20-the-matrix-and-its-cyberpunk-philosophy-still-resonate.

Falzon, Christopher. "The Matrix 20 Years On: How a Sci-Fi Film Tackled Big Philosophical Questions." The Conversation. March 28, 2019. https://theconversation.com/the-matrix-20-years-on-how-a-sci-fi-film-tackled-big-philosophical-questions-114007.

Harvey, David. The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change. Oxford: Blackwell, 1990.

Jameson, Fredric. Postmodernism, or, The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism. Durham: Duke University Press, 1991.

Kehr, Dave. "Philosophers Draw on a Film Drawing on Philosophers." New York Times. May 24, 2003. https://www.nytimes.com/2003/05/24/movies/philosophers-draw-on-a-film-drawing-on-philosophers.html.

LitCharts. "Literature, Realism, and Idealism Theme in Don Quixote." Accessed June 18, 2024. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/don-quixote/themes/literature-realism-and-idealism.

Manlove, C.N. The Fantasy Literature of England. Macmillan Press, 1999.

Originales, George. "Plato, Descartes, and The Matrix." Medium. May 30, 2019. https://medium.com/@george.originales/plato-descartes-and-the-matrix-73f24f8e0bec.

Plato. Republic. Book VII, 514a-520a.

"Plato and Aristotle: How Do They Differ?" Britannica. Accessed June 18, 2024. https://www.britannica.com/story/plato-and-aristotle-how-do-they-differ.

St. Bonaventure University. "The Allegory of the Cave." Accessed June 18, 2024. http://web.sbu.edu/theology/bychkov/plato%20republic%207.pdf.

Soete, Francois de. “Plato, Dickens, and the Soul: Examining the Role of Justice on the Path to Liberation.” The Classical Connection 1, no. 2 (2023). https://doi.org/10.21428/3c891a13.2fad6cf7.

Texas A&M University-Commerce. "Plato's 'Allegory of the Cave.'" Accessed June 18, 2024. https://faculty.tamuc.edu/jherndon/documents/plato.pdf.

Tosenberger, Catherine. "Portal-Quest Fantasy." In The Cambridge Companion to Fantasy Literature, edited by Edward James and Farah Mendlesohn, 1-12. Cambridge University Press, 2012.

Washington State University. "Realism in American Literature." Accessed June 18, 2024. https://public.wsu.edu/~campbelld/amlit/realism.htm.

Neurophilosophy. "The Philosophy of The Matrix." ScienceBlogs. August 4, 2007. https://scienceblogs.com/neurophilosophy/2007/08/04/the-philosophy-of-the-matrix.